Frozen Pizza Brands You Can Find At The Grocery Store, Ranked
By Hunter Reis | June 22, 2024
When hunger strikes and cooking feels like a chore, frozen pizza is a go-to option for many. Convenient, quick, and delicious (most of the time), frozen pizzas have been a staple in grocery stores since the 1950s. However, not all frozen pizzas are created equal. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. That’s why we’ve ranked some of the most popular frozen pizza brands you can find at your local grocery store, considering factors like taste, crust quality, toppings, and overall value.
10. Kroger Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Kroger may dominate the grocery landscape, but their frozen pizza game still leaves much to be desired. Priced at $5.50, this pizza disappoints with its cardboard-like crust and lackluster cheese that looks and tastes artificial. While the marinara sauce has a hearty flavor, it’s not enough to save this pizza from landing at the bottom of the list.
9. Tillamook Three Cheese Pizza
Known for their high-quality dairy products, Tillamook sets high expectations. Unfortunately, their three-cheese pizza falls short. While the cheese blend is rich and stringy, the crust is dense and overly crunchy, and the sauce lacks flavor. At $11 per pizza, it’s hard to justify the price for a product that doesn’t live up to its brand’s reputation.
8. Red Baron Four Cheese Pizza
Red Baron is a budget-friendly option that delivers decent value for its price of under $6. However, the overpowering parmesan flavor and unevenly melted cheese detract from the experience. The use of tomato paste instead of sauce leaves the pizza dry and lacking depth. The thin crust has a nice bite but isn’t enough to elevate this pizza higher on the list.
7. Trader Joe’s Pizza Parlanno
Trader Joe’s offers a variety of pizzas, but the Pizza Parlanno—a supreme-style pizza with sausage, pepperoni, and roasted vegetables—falls in the middle of the pack. While it’s affordable at $5.49, the small size and underwhelming flavor make it less appealing. The crust is thin but lacks crispiness, and the toppings don’t live up to Trader Joe’s usual quality standards.
6. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Pizza
Newman’s Own pizzas stand out for their philanthropic mission—100% of profits go to charity—but the product itself is hit-or-miss. The thin crust is crispy but chewy in parts, and the pepperoni is overly salty. However, the seasoning and flavorful sauce redeem this pizza somewhat, making it a decent option at $8.
5. DiGiorno Hand-Tossed Pepperoni Pizza
DiGiorno is a household name in frozen pizza, and their hand-tossed pepperoni pizza delivers a solid performance. The crust is thick, chewy, and slightly sweet, while the generous tomato sauce adds richness. However, inconsistent topping distribution and limited cheese hold it back from ranking higher. At around $8, it’s a reliable choice for feeding two or more people.
4. Amy’s Cheese Pizza
Amy’s offers a healthier alternative with organic ingredients and a simple yet satisfying cheese pizza. The tangy tomato puree and chewy wheat crust make it feel fresher than your typical frozen pizza. However, its small size and sparse cheese leave something to be desired—especially at $10 per pie.
3. Whole Foods 365 Four Cheese Pizza
For just $5.99, Whole Foods’ 365 frozen pizza is a great deal. The four-cheese blend of mozzarella, fontina, parmesan, and provolone melts beautifully and provides a rich flavor profile. The thin crust has a pleasant crunch, though the pizza could benefit from additional seasoning. Overall, it’s an affordable option with high-quality ingredients.
2. Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust Canadian Bacon & Pineapple Pizza
Freschetta surprises with its flavorful toppings and impressive quality for just $4. The Canadian bacon is thick and savory, while the pineapple remains juicy despite being frozen—a rare feat! The thick crust is airy yet chewy, making for an enjoyable bite every time. Whether you love or hate pineapple on pizza, Freschetta delivers one of the best frozen options available.
1. Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni Pizza
Topping our list is Screamin’ Sicilian’s Holy Pepperoni pizza, which stands out for its generous toppings and bold flavors. The pepperoni is spicy and plentiful, covering every inch of the pie (even the crust!). The mozzarella cheese melts perfectly into the seasoned tomato sauce for a warm and hearty bite. While slightly pricey at $10.50, this pizza is worth every penny for its quality and taste.
FAQs About Frozen Pizzas
1. What’s the best frozen pizza for families?
DiGiorno Hand-Tossed Pepperoni Pizza is a great option for families due to its hearty crust and generous size.
2. Are there any healthy frozen pizzas?
Amy’s Cheese Pizza offers organic ingredients and a wheat crust for a healthier alternative.
3. Which frozen pizza brand has the most toppings?
Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni Pizza takes the crown for its abundance of pepperoni and cheese.
4. Is pineapple on pizza good?
While opinions vary, Freschetta’s Canadian Bacon & Pineapple Pizza proves that pineapple can work wonderfully when paired with quality ingredients.
5. What’s the cheapest frozen pizza worth buying?
Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust pizzas offer excellent quality at just $4.
When it comes to frozen pizzas, there’s something for everyone—from budget-friendly options to gourmet-style pies. Use this guide to navigate your local grocery store’s freezer aisle and find your next favorite slice!
